On the Anniversary of Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s Execution
Answering God’s call is not a task easily undertaken, nor is it without sacrifice. While all will find difficulties along the way, the manner in which an individual faces those challenges will vary greatly. Some may find that the difficulties become too strenuous to continue, perhaps setting limits on the burdens they are willing to bear. Others will continue to follow the call knowing fully well that discipleship is not an easy road, rather, that suffering is frequently the path. Along the way, despite the hardships, the suffering disciple will still find satisfaction and life through serving God. This has been the case with the prophets and prophetic voices in all ages, a list of many names, including Dietrich Bonhoeffer.
Bonhoeffer was born on February 4, 1906, the son of a distinguished doctor, psychiatrist and teacher at Berlin University. Many of Bonhoeffer’s ancestors had been clergy, and a great-grandfather who had been a professor of Church History had been arrested for supporting the rights of students.
His childhood friendships included children of a theologian and an historian. In 1924 he became a theology student at Berlin University, where he came under the influence of Barth, exposed to thoughts of neo-orthodoxy, and the need to move away from religiosity. This influence would come to not only be reflected in his later works, but is also mentioned in some of his Letters.
Beginning in 1930, he studied for a year at Union Theological Seminary in New York, and while there visited several states. He became aware of and began to appreciate the experience of African Americans, often worshipping in a church in Harlem, which began to reshape his worldview of Christianity while at the same time gaining respect for the Jewish faith. He returned to Berlin in order to assume a teaching position at the University.
Bonhoeffer would pastor two German congregations in London, and during that time was forbidden by the Nazi authorities to continue teaching in Berlin. Also happening at the time was the publication of the Barmen Declaration rejecting false doctrine and serving as a foundational document for the “Confessing Church,” a church which would openly denounce Hitler’s policies made in the name of the Gospel. This church subsequently invited Bonhoeffer to return to Germany to be the head of a new covert seminary. Despite being advised by many not to return to Germany he accepted, knowing fully well that doing so might endanger his life.
After returning to Germany and beginning to teach again, he also began to publish his writings. Among the most significant is The Cost of Discipleship, published in 1937. This work, intended as an exposition on the Sermon on the Mount, also contains insight into Bonhoeffer’s personal understanding of what true discipleship means.
But the call of Jesus is stronger than the barrier. At this critical moment nothing on earth, however sacred, must be allowed to come between Jesus and the [person] he has called—not even the law itself. Now, if never before, the law must be broken for the sake of Jesus; it forfeits all its rights if it acts as a barrier to discipleship. Therefore Jesus emerges at this point as the opponent of the law, and commands a [person] to follow him. Only Christ can speak in this fashion. He alone has the last word. His would-be follower can not kick against the pricks. This call, this grace, is irresistible.
It is this understanding of the call and cost of discipleship which he would live out in his life, even through it would mean his later imprisonment and death at the hands of the Nazi regime.
Bonhoeffer had been a pacifist for many years; however, the growing terror of the Nazi regime was causing him to realize that pacifism might be an escape from the call of discipleship. As he began to realize that a person could not just escape into piety and be relieved of responsibility, he became involved in the resistance movement, which eventually led to his arrest by the Gestapo in April 1943. He would be imprisoned until April 9, 1945 when he was executed in a concentration camp. During his captivity he often communicated with friends and family, and it was this correspondence which would later be published posthumously as Letters and Papers from Prison.
During the early portion of his confinement Bonhoeffer remained optimistic about his release, often stating that he did not feel it would be for a great amount of time. Gradually, however, he began to realize that the situation was beyond his control, and his best approach was that of patience. In a letter dated July 3, 1943 (then three months in prison), he wrote that he recalled a lecture on ethics where he heard that it was one of the duties of a Christian citizen to remain patient if imprisoned and waiting for investigation. It served as a reminder to him and others to wait calmly and patiently for the outcome.
It was also during this early portion of his incarceration when he focused on rereading the Bible from cover to cover. In a letter dated Easter 1943, he mentioned a preoccupation with the high priestly prayer from the passion account, and in a subsequent letter dated May 15, he mentioned that he was particularly fond of Job. These two mentions are insightful, as they illustrate Bonhoeffer’s identification with passages of suffering early in his detention.
Another interesting insight is gained from his reference to Jeremiah 45 on two separate occasions. The first is somewhat early, Sept. 5, 1943, where he offered that life extends beyond our physical existence. The second mention comes from the letter dated July 21, 1944, the day after the assassination attempt on Hitler, where he grappled with the meaning of faith.
By this-worldliness I mean living unreservedly in life’s duties, problems, successes and failures, experiences and perplexities. In doing so we throw ourselves completely into the arms of God, taking seriously, not our own sufferings, but those of God in the world—watching with Christ in Gethsemane. That, I think, is faith…and that is how one becomes a [person] and a Christian (cf. Jer 45!).
While no one can suppose to know exactly what in Jeremiah 45 had remained with Bonhoeffer for almost a full year, certainly it may have been the following portion (given his previous statements on discipleship): “Thus says the LORD: I am going to break down what I have built, and pluck up what I have planted– that is, the whole land. And you, do you seek great things for yourself? Do not seek them; for I am going to bring disaster upon all flesh, says the LORD; but I will give you your life as a prize of war in every place to which you may go.” (Jer 45.4-6)
Despite his questioning of the meaning of faith, he realized that truer understanding was to be gained not from an easy life, rather from the struggles and hard times. Reflecting upon the nativity as Christmas approached, combined with an empathetic presence with other prisoners, he wrote the following on Dec. 17, 1943:
For many people in this building it will probably be a more sincere and genuine occasion than in places where nothing but the name is kept…misery, suffering, poverty, lonliness, helplessness, and guilt…these are things that a prisoner can understand better than other people; for him they really are glad tidings, and that faith gives him a part in the commuion of saints, a Christian fellowship breaking the bounds of time and space and reducing the months of confinement here to insignificance.
Five days later, he would write that he had no regrets for his involvement “in the part I had resolved to play in Germany’s fate. It is with no reproach that I look back on the past and accept the present…all we can do is live in assurance and faith.” Through his own writing and actions, Bonhoeffer had accepted the call of Christ as he had described it many years earlier in The Cost of Discipleship (see above), complete with the need to break the law in the name of Christ. It had been for him irresistible, yet the suffering which accompanied his call was informing his understanding of the meaning of true faith.
He had come to a new understanding of what it meant to be a Christian. It was not, as he had written in Discipleship a “Cheap Grace,” rather it was grace that was quite costly. On July 18, 1944, he wrote: “To be a Christian does not mean to be religious in a particular way, to make something of oneself (a sinner, a penitent, or a saint) on the basis of some method or other, but to be a [person]—not a type of [person], but the [person] that Christ creates in us. It is not the religious act that makes the Christian, but participation in the sufferings of God in the secular life.”
Bonhoeffer had taken the road less traveled. It was not the path of easy Christianity, or the way of blissful ignorance of the “outside world.” For him, it was the realization that the call to discipleship was a call to participate in the work and suffering of God through Christ. As a contemporary martyr, perhaps he heard the message of the Gospel through extreme ears. On the other hand, he may have heard the message more clearly than many others. How many countless other pastors saw the state of Germany during those days and turned their backs? How many had chosen the path of least resistance, the choice of inaction? It seems almost as if Hitler had become the new Decius, and when faced with persecution many German Christians reacted out of fear, becoming the “lapsed” of the 20th century.
But this was not the case for Dietrich Bonhoeffer. He chose to hear the call of Christ, even unto his own suffering and death, even unto his own martyrdom. He realized that to discipleship was not a call to serve in the “good times.” True faith would require action, the willingness and commitment to stand for what is right and just in God’s world, despite the consequences. Six months before his death he wrote that “It is certain that we claim nothing for ourselves, and may yet pray for everything; it is certain that our joy is hidden in suffering, and our life in death; it is certain that in all this we are in a fellowship that sustains us. In Jesus God has said Yes and Amen to it all, and that Yes and Amen is the firm ground on which we stand.”
Dietrich Bonhoeffer heard the true call, complete with its many nuances, and responded with his life for Christ. One can not help but wonder how many persons today are prepared to respond with the same strength of commitment and conviction to that call.
“What will come out of my time here it is still too early to say; but something will come of it….”
–Dietrich Bonhoeffer, September 25, 1943
Endnotes:
[1] DietrichBonhoeffer, Letters and Papers from Prison, translated byReginaldFuller (New York: Macmillan, 1967), 19.
[1] Ibid., 19.
[1] These statements are derived from lecture notes ofMay 11, 2005.
[1] Ibid., 20.
[1] JustoL.Gonzalez, The Story of Christianity: Volume 2, The Reformation to the Present Day (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1985), 365.
[1] DietrichBonhoeffer, The Call to Discipleship, et. (New York: Touchstone/Simon & Schuster, 1995), 60-61.
[1] Bonhoeffer, Letters, 59.
[1] Ibid., 43, 46.
[1] Ibid., 65.
[1] Bonhoeffer, Letters, 202.
[1] Ibid., 76.
[1] Ibid., 115.
[1] Ibid., 198.
[1] Bonhoeffer, Letters, 214.
[1] Ibid., 68.
Bibliography
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich. The Cost of Discipleship. Translated by R. H. Fuller. New York: Touchstone/Simon & Schuster, 1995.
Bonhoeffer, Dietrich. Letters and Papers from Prison. Translated by Reginald Fuller. New York: Macmillan Company, 1967.
Gonzalez, Justo L. The Story of Christianity Vol. II: The Reformation to the Present Day. San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 1985.